Q: When is a democracy not a democracy?
A: About six months after its first national election, if the nation is in the Arab Muslim world.
The unspoken reality is that 60-70% of the electorate still live in the 7th century. When they vote, they elect a government as backward as they are. In short order their fledgling democracy devolves into a repressive, fundamentalist, winner-take-all one-party state, which suits them just fine.
While it’s true, as many Islamists point out, that the Arab Muslim world played a pivotal role in bringing Europe out of the Dark Ages and into the Renaissance, their own cultures never experienced that transformation into modernity.
Literacy rates are abysmal. Women have little or no role in the workplace or civil society. Basic principles of tolerance and individual human rights, when actually practiced, are condemned as blasphemy, subject to the death penalty.
The sad irony is that simply instituting “single-use” democracy is futile – 60-70% of the population will remain in the 7th century, either hostile or oblivious to the modern world, delaying real democracy for at least another generation.
The bottom line: the only real prospect for democracy in the region involves using non-democratic means to shift the demographic balance of power to those who live in the current century.
In Egypt that means supporting the military’s efforts to install a moderate, civilian-led secular government that will institute modernization of the economy and the educational system. In Jordan it means supporting the relatively enlightened and cosmopolitan monarchy.
Elsewhere in the region? Well, that’s the elephant in the room…



